5 ways to talk about love

This post started because someone in one of my discussion groups asked "Why do people pursue romantic love?" He claimed to have never been in love and to not understand the experience. He asked why people think it worthwhile, if  they do.

After many had weighed in with their ideas, I found myself thinking about songs that best express what is worthwhile about love. Of course there are endless answers to this question and I might answer differently depending on the day, but these are the ones that came to mind at the time.

1) Love found. I think the song "Now I see the Light" from the movie Tangled captures the transformative experience of finding love.  "Now that I see you": the lover sees the divine in his/her beloved. In true love  for another we see what is good and beautiful in the world. The part is the whole, and the whole is the part.

"And at last I see the light
And it's like the fog has lifted
And at last I see the light
And it's like the sky is new
And it's warm and real and bright
And the world has somehow shifted
All at once everything looks different
Now that I see you"





2) Love Lost. Leonard Cohen's "Hallejulah" both shows the pain of losing love and is a refusal to sink into despair.

 "Even though it all went wrong, I'll stand up here before the lord of song, with nothing on my tongue by Hallejulah."






3) Love when it's a struggle: One True Love, by Jill Barber, sung by Jill and Matthew Barber

This song explores why love is worth fighting for.  We do not get the impression that the speaker in the song has had an easy life. He or she has made mistakes, but has found a love worth standing up for. I love the throwaway relativism of "If you believe in that sorta thing" in the chorus contrasted with the speaker's firm belief that there is one true love.

Below is the live acoustic version. Look how cute they are! But I do actually prefer the non-acoustic version because it suits the aggressive nature of the lyrics. This song will get in your personal space and elevate your heart rate, in a good way.

Tooth and nail I would fight for you
Use my heart like a fist till it’s black and blue
Cause when you find your one true love
That is the time to show what you are made of

Sure I’ve loved and lost before
Bitten and bruised and sorry and sore
But this time I am back for more
And to fight

[Chorus]
For your one true love
Your one true love
If you believe in that sorta thing like I do
Your one true love
Your one true love
If you believe in that sorta thing like I do





4) Seeking, but not (yet) finding love: "No One Talks" by Moya Brennan

It is extremely hard to be looking for love and not finding it. If this struggle goes on for any length of time, then often people wonder, is there something wrong with me? is love even real? is looking for it worthwhile? It can be easy to make excuses to give up, to not bother. This song is about questioning those impulses and pushing through. Looking for love can force you to confront what you actually believe about yourself and life and can be an impetus to transform.

Now no one talks, no one to listen
No one to laugh with to share a life
Now no one cries, no one to pray with
Now who will love?
Is this what you believe?
Is this what you believe?
That no one loves, no one to warm to
Does no one care?






5) So finally, how did I come to believe what I believe about love? Well, I could write books about that, as could most people if so inclined. But I will just say here, this next song went though my head over and over when I was living abroad, and when I started to listen to it, I think it taught me something about myself, and maybe life in general.

Youth will in time decay, Eileen Aroon
Beauty must fade away, Eileen Aroon
Castles are sacked in war, chieftains are scattered far
Truth is a fixed star, Eileen Aroon

I need and want my "fixed star." I don't mind the long journey, the doubt, the uncertainty, the complexity of the world. All this I accept, and more than that, I find it fascinating. But I also believe in following the "fixed star." We will make mistakes on the way and get lost, and believe wrong and foolish things. This is inevitable. More important is to know where we are going and what we are aiming at. Love is something worth aiming at, whether or not at the present moment one can grasp it.

Judgment

There is a lot of talk in the chattering classes I frequent about judgment. Who to judge, how you judge, how you know if the judgment is fair. Well actually I am over intellectualizing it. I wonder about who and what and why, but that’s not usually the focus of what I read.  Social media is full of constant exhortations to judge this person or that group, or to NOT judge this person or group.

 Most of the time, to be honest, I don’t know remotely enough about the person/people in question to judge them. For example the other day acquaintances shared these first person accounts, one from a parent, one from a child talking about an aspect of their identity and how it shouldn’t be judged negatively. So the people in question might be well balanced, intentioned, and trying to be their best selves. Believing that makes me sound very tolerant and open minded. Or, they might be a train wreck of self deception, poor relationships and manipulation. Hmmmm, not so open minded now. But is option B any less likely or probable than option A? As far as I can tell, no.

I do try to not assume that worst of people. Johnathon Haidt talks about this in The Coddling of the American Mind and I have thought about it a lot. At the same time, not assuming the worst is not the same as assuming the best. I’m not so eager to do that either.  

Truthfully, I do judge. Everybody judges. I believe in nuance but also clarity: they both have their place. My life is the outcome of a series of judgments and some of them could look fairly harsh from one point of view.  But there is a difference between judging ideas and judging people. You can reject an idea without totally condemning another person’s life, which you probably don’t know that much about anyway. I can also decide to avoid certain outcomes in my life without viewing people who didn’t / couldn’t avoid those outcomes in a bad light. 

If I think about the majority of the judgments in my life, they have mainly involved judging certain ideas / beliefs / ways of looking at the world to be insufficient.  Sometimes it was a sharp judgment and sometimes it developed over time.  But the most useful judgments are not about individual people (much as I might agree or disagree with their decisions) but people in aggregate. I look for patterns. Specifically patterns that apply to people kinda like me. What works, what doesn’t.

In summary, I think judgment is a very good thing but one should judge with pragmatism. Like anything else, a judgement should be useful not just generate a lot of negative emotion.

Christmas Eve 2019: part 2

So I continue my thoughts on Christmas Eve after we left St Barnabas Anglican, had dinner with my mom and husband, and carried on home to get ready for Christmas Day tomorrow. Of course there were toys to pick up off the floor, which I cajoled AJ to help with so Santa Claus wouldn’t trip and fall when he came to our house. Then we put out milk and cookies and a carrot, took a photo of two very excited girls and tucked them into bed. Then there were a few more things to do, including wrapping the presents from Santa which would be a surprise Christmas morning. I don’t push the Santa thing much, not having grown up with it and finding it a tad weird, to be honest, but I don’t mind playing that game with the girls as long as they find it fun. NORAD’s Santa tracker on Christmas Eve adds the element of realism I can’t be much bothered with.

Anyway, by the time I was able to get into bed I must have been a bit too wound up to go right to sleep, and as I often do if I’m not dead tired, I look for a podcast to listen to. Jonathon Pageau’s Christian Life and Symbolic Living seemed like a good choice.....and it turned out to have unnerving relevance to my thoughts during the service. I will try to summarize the parts that stood out for me here, for my benefit and that of those who are interested, but of course I recommend listening to the original.

Pageau’s theme was why the practise of Christianity is relevant in modern times and why going to church and following traditions holds society and individuals together. 

He begins with a bold statement: when you go to church, you are “participating in the existence of the world.” And he goes on to say that this is a defensible statement, and to explain why.

Human consciousness is what brings shape to the world. People name parts of the world and beyond that, people perceive how groups of things are also coherent wholes.  For example, we know a family is a family and not just a group of unrelated individuals. A country is also more than just its parts. Purpose is what makes groups cohere and purpose is what we see when we look at the world.

Science looks at how things work and the way the pieces of each thing function together. However, science has overlooked how human consciousness functions to see meaning and unity in the world. (That is how I so far understand his argument; it might be better explained in other lectures). Now that we have tried for a hundred years or more to organize society without religion, it is easier to see the failures of this way of living.

Pageau gives the example of how a medieval town was put together: the church was built first, then houses, then farmland around it, then public buildings and markets. Small towns in his home province of Quebec were built this way. The church was always the highest point, so it could be seen from everywhere in the town.  This reminded people of their common purpose.

A group can be united by any purpose: knitting, collecting, making music for example. But in a church people are supposed to be centring the highest purpose, and this makes churches unique among other groups. Likewise going to church and following the rituals helps align the individual with her highest purpose. The communal rites, saying the same words, looking in the same direction, coming to the same place, create unity and strengthen resolve and purpose. 

Pageau contrasts this picture with how secular societies attempt to build communities. They build suburbs. There is no centre to a suburb, nothing that unifies people or reminds them of a common purpose. It is normal to not know your neighbours a few doors down. It is possible for there to be someone in the community that nobody talks to or is aware of at all.

Later in the talk an audience member asks Pageau what he thinks of malls. The speaker has fond memories of going to malls in his youth and hanging out with friends. It was not a spiritual experience but it was a place where people came together. However, he observes that now malls are starting to go away, replaced by online shopping. He asks what Pageau thinks of this?

Pageau answers by talking about hierarchy: the church is at top, then beneath it the state, then the market, etc. When the top piece is ignored or removed, then people turn to the next piece on the hierarchy for meaning. But eventually each one fails. The state doesn’t unite people, neither does the market (the mall), and then finally people turn to increasingly fragmented groups online.

This argument could use some more exploring for sure, but it certainly is relatable for me. In fact I saw an example of it on New Year’s Eve a few days later. Again my husband was working and I tried to think what I could do to make New Year’s Eve a bit special for myself and our daughters. I looked for family friendly events in our city and saw one at a nearby mall. So we got dressed up and off we went, not without a few tears and fuss as that is often how it goes. 

 When we got to the mall we saw that a great many people had had the same idea: five thousand was a number someone later claimed. We went to the centre of the mall, looking for the unifying purpose as Pageau might put it. There was a deejay and some laser lights and a dance floor, and a lot of people, but nobody seemed to really know what to do.  No one was actually dancing, and though more and more people kept pressing in on us I increasingly wondered why any of us bothered to be there at all. We finally left for another slightly less crowded part of the mall.   But the kids were bored and confused and I was left with a sense of existential doom: I was surrounded by people, but none of us had anything in common except that we were all looking for something that wasn’t there. Quite a difference from my experience at St Barnabas Anglican.

But that is getting a bit ahead of myself. As I lay in bed listening to this podcast, my experiences on Christmas Eve fresh in my mind and the anticipated ones of Christmas Day looming, I felt that there was a message in these two events. I felt, and still feel, that I need to find a community centred on a higher purpose. I see how I have tried to do this sporadically in my life, and have succeeded, often not knowing quite how to define the success. I have acted intuitively at times and ignored my intuition at others. I have looked for higher purpose in my own relationships and work and pastimes, and I have found it, but I have also fragmented and lost confidence and interest in things trivial and crucial.

I see in myself the desperate seeking of novelty and distraction.  I have tried mindfulness and meditation, and indeed it has helped through some tough moments. But my mind is restless and refuses to be merely soothed. I want to stay functional to meet my considerable responsibilities, but I cringe at the thought of taking medication to dull my thoughts and feelings. More than any of this I want to be truthful in my thoughts and words and actions, and while I don’t think I’m a liar, I don’t think I tell the whole truth either. I need to try. I need to be the kind of person who can say what needs to be said. And since I am alive, here, now, I can do it.

Those are my thoughts as I wrap up my first entries on my blog. It’s getting late; I will probably look for something to listen to now and set a sleep timer. Tomorrow I start the second half of the school year and a very busy and challenging month. I don’t know how much progress I will make on this project of religious exploration. I hope I can keep up the thinking and researching. I did discuss these ideas with Mr Turtle over dinner in my birthday, and found him if similar mind, which was very encouraging. And a couple of people have expressed some interest in this blog. I hope to be back to explore, and I feel good for finishing these two first entries, because they were a lot of work. It’s not a small thing, to grow your life and mind and soul.

Christmas Eve 2019: part 1

I had a couple of synchronous events happen on Christmas Eve this past December, and the thoughts, feelings and the desire to do something about  them have stayed with me. In so far as I have a goal for 2020 other then surviving, it is forming around this experience.

Here is the first part.

Mr. Turtle had to work until 5pm Christmas Eve, as did other family. So there were no big plans for this day, but I wanted to do something with the girls to make it memorable. I had an idea to go to a Christmas Eve service. But which church? There are a few in our neighbourhood; however I thought to include my mom (she is elderly and a widow) it would make more sense to choose one near her. She still lives in the house I grew up in, and a five minute walk away is St. Barnabus Anglican.

 I have a small connection with this church because many years ago, from the ages of 8 till 12 roughly, I took ballet lessons from a teacher who rented space in the church hall. Although we were not formally connected with the church we were involved a couple of times with their events. One was a Christmas musical production of Cinderella. We did a couple of dances: one was to The Teddy Bears’ Picnic and for the other we wore fluffy tutus and were part of the ball scene. It was my first time performing on a stage and therefore made a big impression. The second time was part of a St George’s day celebration and we learned and performed an English folk dance. These are good memories from my childhood, and they provide a connection to the church, which while tenuous is still more than I have to any other church. Those were sufficient reasons to choose it for our Christmas Eve outing.

I had no serious worries we wouldn’t be welcome, but I was still a bit nervous when the time came. I told myself it was ok to try something new.  5 year old AJ was enthusiastic, although she had never been in a church before and the closest thing she had seen to a service was Elsa’s coronation from Frozen.  We had read her some Bible stories in the past year, when she showed an interest. She received them much as she did fairy tales or any other story, coolly observing “But God isn’t real,” and assuming adult support for this statement, while we said things like  “well nobody knows for sure” and privately thought: “We really need a strategy here.....” Dani, almost 23 months, was ready for any adventure we cared to offer.

It was a beautiful evening, a winter dusk glowing blue with snow light.  I was reminded of childhood walks through the neighbourhood (although never to church).  The crunch of snow underfoot, the shining streetlights, the warmth and welcome of my family’s home after an evening of swimming or a ballet lesson. Or perhaps we might be walking up the hill to see an opera or a ballet at the auditorium. My dad always made sure we had season tickets to the opera, ballet or symphony, whatever other luxuries we overlooked in our frugal lifestyle. 

As we approached the church we saw people gathering for the service and we entered with them. The church was lovely inside: brightly lit with blond wood accents, high ceiling, stained glass windows, tall candles burning. The adults were handed a program and the kids were given glow sticks, which immediately interested then in the proceedings. They were also supposed to have musical instruments, but somehow we missed those.

I was half paying attention to what was going on and the other half focused on my mom and kids. They were fine though; AJ and Dani were curious enough enough about what was going on to stay engaged and not become overly restless.  As the service began I took it in with my available attention and found my mind bringing up different thoughts and memories in an effort to relate.

• I followed others’ lead for the parts of the service where people spoke different words together, and felt awkward trying to find the right hymn in the right book, etc. But I appreciated the poetry of the communally spoken verses. Again I reminded myself it was better to do something awkwardly than not at all. Just showing up was enough for now: no need to have further expectations. 
• The service included many references to the darkness of winter, and the return of the light, which was associated with Jesus. This made me think about how many cultures have rituals around the solstice, and the discussion of how Christianity adopted rituals from other cultures. I have never thought this was a big deal or really that relevant as more than interesting information. I would think it stranger for people to not learn from each other and adapt and adopt.
•  I also thought of my self consciously non-Christian or New Agey acquaintances who post things like “Blessed Solstice” or whatever instead of “Merry Christmas” around this time of year. I find those statements a bit off key: what exactly is the significance of an astronomical event if you aren’t clear about the meanings you are attaching to it? Perhaps the people who say “Happy Solstice” do have a meaning in their mind, but it is never plain to me what that is, or if I am just supposed to read whatever I want into the statement. I prefer the Christian rite where the solstice is attached to a story with significance.
• The most relatable part of the service was singing Christmas carols. And I knew them well enough that I could sing mostly without looking at the words, which allowed me to feel more a part of the celebration. Singing with others is a powerful transformative experience as is dancing with others; this is not the first time such an experience has taken me to another level of awareness. 
• Singing the carols reminded me of why I am familiar with Christmas carols.  For several years in my 20s and early 30s,  I would get together with friends and sing carols around the neighbourhood. It was always a fun time of laughter and bonding and the spontaneous pleasure of surprising people with song and neighbourly spirit. After a hiatus of many years a friend and I organized a caroling evening last year, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. But this year our lives were too chaotic to make plans.
• For many years (but not the last 5) I also played music with an adult concert band, and the Christmas concert was a yearly tradition.  Starting in November each band and choir would begin practicing their Christmas repertoire. The end of every concert was a Christmas sing along where the audience would get to their feet and sing a medley of carols with the bands. It never occurred to me that this tradition echoed a church service but now I saw that it did. I both missed the experience of playing in a band and having that yearly ritual and found it interesting to see the origin of it.
• A family with children a few years older than mine was invited to help with some of the service, such as lighting advent candles. They wore special white robes.  At one point the pastor also invited all the children to come up front to hear the nativity story. AJ and Dani were curious but too shy to go. It was then that I had the thought: what if I had grown up coming to this church and these rituals had become second nature? What if my parents had overcome their fear of organized religion (that is a whole other story) and we had walked to St Barnabas every week to sing songs and speak words about faith? How would that have affected me as a person? I thought it would have likely been mostly positive. And what if my mother had had a community to turn to and support her when my father died? What if she had familiar people around her in widowhood instead of facing the nearly impossible task of forming new friendships as an elderly woman who is declining cognitively? 
• Or, remembering a different time of my life: what if I had had a faith to turn to in my early adulthood? Almost 20 years ago, I was having the most memorable experience of my university years.  I was studying Old English and found my mind and heart stirred by the early medieval story of Caedmon’s hymn . Caedmon is an awkward, tongue tied cowherd who is too shy to recite poetry at the local pub. One night an angel visits Caedmon in a dream and commands him to sing a song. He wakes up with the words of the first recorded poem in English rolling off his tongue, about the creation of the world. In my fourth year of university I found myself similarly commanded. I wrote a poem as the final course project, and over the next year and a half it turned into an honours thesis. Working on my long poem was the most profound and glorious experience of my life thus far. Caedmon came into my life to give it a direction: of that I was sure. I did the best I could back then, both on the undergrad project and on the next two decades of adventure and growth. But if it was God questioning me through this story (and I wonder that seriously), did I have the full vocabulary in my youth to give an answer? I remember sitting in my advisor’s office trying to say I wanted to explore the relationship between Caedmon and God, but I became painfully embarrassed and couldn’t find the words. Despite the ecstatic nature of my personal experience, my poem was carefully secular though composed with all the love I could muster. What was I afraid of? I still can’t answer that.  If I had had a faith tradition to turn to, would I have had more confidence?

Of course, I am speculating about all these things, and very optimistically.  It is equally possible for organized religion to go wrong, to disappoint, to be destructive. And indeed, that is the side of it I know most about.

But even as I wondered about missed opportunities in the past, and acknowledged the feelings of curiosity and regret that followed, another thought swiftly overtook the first.  I am an adult now, with plenty of life still ahead (I assume) and the capacity to make decisions and set a direction. I do not need to be restrained by past fears or doubts. I can evolve. I can ask questions and seek answers. 

And indeed I have a responsibility to ask what sort of adult I should be, and to update the answer based on my most recent experience and insight. It is true that I had bad experiences with organized religion as a child. I saw and experienced the damage it did to my immediate and extended family.  I felt the difference between my personal experience of God and what the collective told me I should experience. All this is real. But as I participated in the service amid the light and the song, I thought I am not meant to be a cynical, fearful, defensive person. I am not meant to be the hurt, confused and frightened child that the cynical person is trying to protect. I can acknowledge that frightened child and respect that part of my experience without needing to BE that person for the rest of my life.  Because there is more to me. I have experienced beauty and truth. I have reached out and found the best in people. I have experienced the miracles of my own children, their perfect bodies and souls. There is so much that is good and expansive and joyful that I cannot and should not deny. But, I admit I need help. I don’t think I can be the person I am meant to be on my own. 

Here we are

This is a blog to write about some of the unexplored territory I am venturing into.

I will write about ideas and plans that are challenging to me but I believe worth making reality.

Stay tuned....